The Naturalness of Believing in Gods: Why Children Hold the Key to Understanding Religious Belief

Romans 1:20

“For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made.” Matthew 18:3

“And said, "Truly I say to you, unless you are converted and become like children, you will not enter the kingdom of heaven.”

The pervasiveness of religious belief across cultures and throughout history is a fascinating phenomenon. Why do the majority of people believe in gods? While the answer may seem straightforward – that children are indoctrinated by their parents and communities – recent research suggests a more nuanced explanation. By exploring the cognitive tendencies of children, we can gain valuable insights into the widespread appeal of religious ideas.

Children's Innate Predisposition to See Purpose and Design

Children possess a natural inclination to perceive the world around them as purposeful and designed. They tend to see intentionality behind natural events and objects. This tendency, often referred to as "promiscuous teleology," leads children to attribute functions and goals to things like rocks, trees, and even the sun. For example, a child might say that a mountain exists "for climbing" or that clouds are "for making rain."

This inclination to see purpose and design in the natural world makes children particularly receptive to the idea of a creator god. When faced with the complexity and order of the universe, children are naturally inclined to believe that someone, rather than something, must be responsible. This intuitive belief in a divine creator provides a simple and satisfying explanation for the world's existence and its intricate workings.

The Limits of Indoctrination

While parental and societal influence undoubtedly plays a role in shaping children's religious beliefs, it cannot fully account for the universality of such beliefs. Studies have shown that children's ideas about gods often diverge from what they are explicitly taught. For instance, children may develop concepts of gods that are more powerful and knowledgeable than those presented by their parents or religious leaders.

Furthermore, children raised in secular households or exposed to multiple religious traditions still exhibit a tendency to believe in supernatural agents and forces. This suggests that the human mind is naturally predisposed to entertain religious ideas, even in the absence of explicit religious instruction.

The Role of Intuitive Thinking

Children's cognitive development is characterized by a reliance on intuitive thinking, which is often guided by emotions and gut feelings rather than logical reasoning. This type of thinking makes children more susceptible to accepting explanations that feel right or emotionally satisfying, even if they lack empirical evidence.

Religious narratives, with their emphasis on supernatural beings and events, often tap into children's intuitive thinking. Stories of gods, miracles, and an afterlife provide simple and emotionally resonant answers to complex questions about the origins of the universe, the meaning of life, and the nature of death.

The Persistence of Religious Beliefs

The cognitive tendencies that make children receptive to religious ideas often persist into adulthood. Even as individuals develop more sophisticated reasoning abilities, their early intuitions about purpose, design, and supernatural agency can continue to influence their worldview.

Moreover, religious beliefs often become deeply intertwined with personal identity, social connections, and cultural traditions. This makes it difficult for individuals to abandon their beliefs, even when confronted with contradictory evidence or alternative explanations.

Conclusion

The widespread belief in gods across cultures and throughout history can be attributed, in part, to the natural cognitive tendencies of children. Their inclination to see purpose and design in the natural world, coupled with their reliance on intuitive thinking, makes them particularly receptive to religious ideas.

While parental and societal influence undoubtedly plays a role in shaping children's religious beliefs, it cannot fully account for the universality of such beliefs. Children's innate predisposition to entertain religious ideas suggests that the human mind is naturally inclined towards spirituality.

By understanding the cognitive foundations of religious belief in children, we can gain a deeper appreciation for the enduring appeal of religion in human societies. This knowledge can also help us to engage in more productive dialogues about religion, fostering greater understanding and respect across different belief systems.

Link